In this edition of Red Carpet Report Card, Lily Collins  will be graded on her Balmain Pre-Fall 2012 look worn to the Writers  premiere during the 2012 Toronto Film Festival. See how she looked after the jump.

Lily will be rated on the below categories, five being the highest and 1 being the lowest.

What grade did Lily receive? Check out page two to find out.

I absolutely love this dress on Lily and am so glad she wore it on the red carpet, even though the photographer blew it out with his flash and made it look shitty in this photo. But the Casadei shoes are horrendous. Love the color, hate the shape, heel height and general conservative nature of what's going on down there. She should be in a boot or very high, thick strappy sandal. The hair and makeup is gorgeous, there's no arguing about that. Different shoes and a belt would have made this look an easy A.