Edited by Jessica Lapidos
Last night, Haley Reinhart got me hot and bothered for Lady Gaga‘s new single You and I as she busted it out in that sultry tone of hers. It was a bold move, as this song hasn’t even hit the airwaves yet, but with Mother Monster’s personal blessing, she gave this tune its national debut. I could hear Gaga in every corner of the song, even though I’ve never heard the Lady sing it. Yet Haley totally owned her performance. I clapped in my living room. Instead of the expected “She’s in it to win it!” from Randy, the ever niceties of J.Lo, and the weirdly phrased praises from Steven Tyler, the three went around dissing her schtick. I watched shocked. Outraged! For shame. That girl is a monster!